Democrats lead with their left

Democrats lead with their left

Democratic hopefuls shake hands and talk after the party's first debate ahead of the 2020 elections. | Joe Raedle/Getty Images 2020 democratic debates Democrats lead with their left It's not an illusion: The party is presenting its most liberal face since the 1970s. By JOHN F. HARRIS 06/27/2019 02:21 AM EDT Share on Facebook Share…

Democratic candidates

Democratic hopefuls shake hands and talk after the party’s first debate ahead of the 2020 elections. | Joe Raedle/Getty Images

2020 democratic debates

Democrats lead with their left

It’s not an illusion: The party is presenting its most liberal face since the 1970s.

There are people who argue that the Democratic Party’s steady leftward progression during the Trump years is largely an optical illusion — a distorted impression one gets from assigning too much significance to social media noise or flamboyant figures like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

Ten Democrats making their case to be president on a debate stage in Miami Wednesday night suggest a much different conclusion.

Story Continued Below

This is a party eager to go on the ideological offensive not just against Donald Trump (whose name did not dominate the evening even as he was invoked plenty) but against an economic and political power structure that candidates argued is deeply corrupt. Liberals must be empowered to bring bad actors to heel through robust intervention of government.

Over the course of two hours, people who are inarguably some of the party’s most consequential and ascendant figures endorsed the mandatory abolition of private health insurance, sharply higher taxes on the wealthy, the decriminalization of illegal border crossings. They spoke with contempt about the alleged profiteering, manipulation, and cruelty of corporations. They argued that ordinary Americans are right to feel screwed, and multiple candidates boasted that they are tough enough to turn the screws on the victimizers, for a change.

Elizabeth Warren, because of her climb in this year’s polls, arrived on the first-night stage as the most commanding figure, and that impression seemed to be reinforced at the outset by the attention she got from NBC’s team of moderators and by the fluency and force of many of her answers, especially on economic matters.

An early defining moment came when anchor Lester Holt asked for a show of hands of “who here would abolish their private health insurance in favor of a government-run plan?” Warren was one of two (New York mayor Bill de Blasio the other) who clearly raised her hand.


The race for 2020 starts now. Stay in the know. Follow our presidential election coverage.

With only a few exceptions, this group of Democrats believes that more urgent problems (economic inequality, climate change) and more malevolent foes (Trump, Mitch McConnell) have changed the landscape. The party’s now seemingly subordinate centrist wing clearly will wonder: are you sure these have changedeverything?

At times, NBC moderators seemed to be exploring for ideological friction, and several questions seemed on the theme of,Are you worried your opponent is too far out there?

But they often had trouble getting takers. Sen. Cory Booker was asked about his apparent disagreement with Warren about calling out individual companies by name for public censure.

“I don’t think I disagree,” he responded, underscoring the point by inveighing against Amazon, Halliburton, and “monopolistic” drug companies, many of which are headquartered in his state.

Klobuchar, pressed by a questioner, acknowledged mildly that she is concerned about the costs of some rivals’ plans, such as free four-year college, but she didn’t accept the invitation to be an evangelist for fiscal responsibility. Instead she touted her own plan for free community college and struck a populist note: “If billionaires can pay off their yachts, students should be able to pay off their student loans.”

It fell largely to emphatically back-of-the-pack candidates like former Rep. John Delaney to stand up for something like the political gospel of Clinton or even Barack Obama (since mandatory Medicare for All amounts to a repeal of the Affordable Care Act.) “100 million Americans say they like their private health insurance,” Delaney said. “We should give everyone in this country health care as a basic human right for free, full stop. But we should also give them the option to buy private insurance. Why do we have to stand for taking away something from people?”

O’Rourke also said that private insurance, especially that negotiated by unions for their members, has an important role.

As much as specific policy proposals, it was the language that suggested changing winds within the party. De Blasio vowed he would stand up to Trump’s argument that illegal immigrants are damaging America with a different argument to working class voters: “For all the American citizens out there who feel you’re falling behind or feel the American dream is not working for you, the immigrants didn’t do that to you. The big corporations did that to you. The one percent did that to you.”

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter

Elizabeth Warren

  • Elizabeth Warren 2020
  • Julian Castro
  • Julian Castro 2020
  • Amy Klobuchar
  • Amy Klobuchar 2020
  • Bill de Blasio
  • Bernie Sanders
  • Bernie Sanders 2020
  • Cory Booker
  • Cory Booker 2020
  • John Delaney
  • Pete Buttigieg
  • Pete Buttigieg 2020
  • 2020 Elections
  • 2020 Presidential Candidates
  • Beto O’Rourke
  • Beto O’Rourke 2020
  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
  • 2020 Democratic Debates
  • POLITICO Playbook and get the latest news, every morning — in your inbox.
    Show Comments

    Most Read

  • Most of the 2020 Democratic candidates are already doomed
  • 7 big takeaways from the first Democratic debate
  • Democrats brawl in bid for breakout moment
  • Who won the debate?
  • Trump allies pressuring DHS chief to resign
  • Trump on what he tells Putin: ‘It’s none of your business’
  • Sanders gets testy when asked about exiting primary
  • Waters backs down in Ex-Im fight after internal struggle
  • The first 2020 Democratic debate, in photos
  • President Donald Trump speaks before signing an executive order to increase sanctions on Iran, in the Oval Office of the White House, Monday, June 24, 2019, in Washington. Trump is accompanied by Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin, left, and Vice President Mike Pence.

    What Trump Really Just Told the Iranians: He’s Out of Ideas.

  • 10 Democratic presidential candidates line up onstage

    ‘An Odd Stretch of Forgettable White Guys Yelling at Each Other’

  • Elizabeth Warren

    The Landmine that Just Got Laid for Elizabeth Warren

  • Óscar Alberto Martínez Ramírez and his daughter Valeria

    Whose Deaths Aren’t We Seeing?

  • Read More