The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has launched investigations into three prominent UK businesses: Bannatyne Health Club, Secret Escapes, and Caledonian Travel. These investigations stem from concerns that customers may have been shown only partial or misleading prices during the booking or signing-up process, with additional charges added later rather than included in the initial price.
What the CMA is investigating
The CMA is examining whether businesses have followed rules on price transparency. Each investigation focuses on a different type of service and charge.
Bannatyne Health Club
The CMA is looking at whether joining fees and facility charges—like steam rooms or fitness classes—were shown at first or added later. A customer might see a £30 monthly membership, only to find a £60 joining fee later. The inquiry checks if these charges were clearly explained from the start.
Secret Escapes
Secret Escapes is under review for missing resort fees, local taxes, and ATOL fees. These charges are often mandatory and can add significantly to the total cost. The CMA also checks whether flight parts and other holiday elements were clearly shown in the initial offer.
Caledonian Travel
Caledonian Travel is being examined for compulsory charges like single-person supplements and city taxes. These fees are usually unavoidable and added at the final booking stage. The CMA checks whether these charges were clearly shown from the beginning.
What the law requires
Since April 2025, UK law requires businesses to include all unavoidable charges in the total price shown at the start of a booking. This stops ‘drip pricing’—when a price looks low at first, then hidden charges appear later.
Businesses can charge for optional extras, like room upgrades. But unavoidable charges must be included upfront. If the final cost can’t be known early, businesses must clearly explain how it’s calculated.
What to check before booking
Don’t trust the first price you see. Check the full cost for everyone in your group. Include booking fees, local taxes, resort charges, and single-person supplements.
Verify what’s included—like flights, baggage, and transfers. Some charges may appear at arrival, but that doesn’t mean they’re not part of the advertised price. Compare full costs across options, not just starting prices.
What about gym memberships?
Ask about joining fees, included facilities, and contract length. Some memberships let you leave monthly. Others require long-term commitments—like one or two years. Always check cancellation rules and notice periods.
If you already have a gym membership, review your payments. Forgotten subscriptions can add up over time.
A simple example: Gym membership costs
Consider two examples:
- One gym charges £30 monthly with a £60 joining fee.
- Another charges £32 monthly with no joining fee.
The cheapest monthly rate isn’t always the best value. A full cost analysis is needed.
What if you’ve already paid an unexpected charge?
Depending on the booking, you may have rights to avoid paying undisclosed fees. Under the Package Travel Regulations 2018, if extra fees weren’t clearly shown before booking, you don’t have to pay them.
But this protection doesn’t cover all charges. For gym memberships booked online or over the phone, a 14-day cooling-off period applies. You can cancel and get a refund—though you may still owe for services already used if the membership started right away.
If you signed up in person, there’s no automatic 14-day right to cancel, especially if you’ve already used services.
What to do if a charge wasn’t made clear
If you paid more than expected, follow these steps:
- Review all documents—booking confirmations, emails, and screenshots of the original price.
- Write to the business formally, explaining which charge wasn’t clear and asking for a refund or explanation.
- If they refuse, submit a formal complaint and request a written response.
- Seek advice from Citizens Advice. They can help you decide if you have a valid claim or if you can challenge the charge through your bank.
Citizens Advice can be contacted at 0808 223 1133 in England and Wales. They can also pass concerns to Trading Standards if needed.
Could customers get refunds?
Refunds are possible—but only if the CMA finds a breach of consumer law. If a breach is confirmed, the CMA can fine businesses up to 10% of their worldwide turnover and order compensation for affected customers.
Being a customer of Bannatyne, Secret Escapes, or Caledonian Travel doesn’t guarantee a refund. The investigations are early stage, with updates expected in April 2027.
You don’t need to wait for the CMA’s final report to act. If you’ve already paid an unexpected charge, raise it with the business right away.
When booking a holiday or joining a gym, always check the full cost. Price transparency is both a legal rule and a sign of fair business practice.
Source: Skint Dad
Sources & further reading
Featured image: Photo: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels. Via original publisher. Image source
