John Harris, a Guardian columnist, argues that the UK’s deepening crisis of youth unemployment—known as the Neets issue—is not about lack of jobs, but about the quality and dignity of work itself. Source: theguardian.com.
The Core Problem Is Not Neets
John Harris challenges the common narrative that the rise of Neets—people not in education, employment, or training—is due to insufficient job opportunities. Instead, he contends that the real issue lies in how capitalism has transformed work over decades. The focus has shifted from meaningful employment to low-wage, insecure roles with little respect or dignity.
What work should give us, Harris says, is everyday pride and contentment. This sense of achievement is missing in today’s labour market. It is not merely a matter of job numbers or availability; it is about the emotional, psychological, and social dimensions of work. When people do not feel valued, seen, or respected in their jobs, they are less likely to remain engaged, motivated, or committed—especially when they are young and forming their identities.
A British Amnesia About Work
There is a widespread amnesia in Britain about what work once meant. In the postwar period, trade unions and a strong social conscience shaped a labour market where workers had real power and respect. The economic model of that era was not one of exploitation but of mutual obligation—between employers, employees, and society at large.
While that system was not perfect—there were biases, gendered exclusion, and paternalistic practices—it delivered better conditions for ordinary people. For instance, in South Wales coalfields, working-class men earned well, wore suits, and enjoyed holidays abroad. Nicky Wire, of the Manic Street Preachers, recalls his father, a miner, who worked hard and was respected. A memorial stone reads: ‘Father, son, brother, worker.’ This phrase is not just a tribute—it is a statement of cultural value. It reflects a society where work was not a burden but a source of identity, pride, and belonging.
That kind of pride is now rare. Harris points to research showing a sharp decline in job satisfaction. The Resolution Foundation found that only 55% of workers now say they would work harder to help their employer succeed—down from a decade ago. Job interest has dropped from 74% to 63%. Opportunities for advancement have fallen from 35% to 26%.
What Milburn’s Report Misses
Alan Milburn’s recent review of youth employment contains thorough research and urgent tone. Yet it lacks a meaningful examination of ‘bad work’—a central issue in his work on Neets. The report blames state benefits, education, and health policies. It notes a long-term decline in entry-level jobs and youth apprenticeships. It also points to reduced employer investment in training.
It proposes a new bargain between government and employers to create more opportunities for young people. But current whispers suggest this may mean less demand on employers, not more. Milburn says employers face higher costs, fragmented support, and rule uncertainty. He claims they are treated as problems, not solutions.
His concerns about new workplace laws—especially in hospitality and retail—may be misplaced. A TUC report found that these sectors suffer from low pay and job insecurity. Such conditions contribute to mental distress and economic inactivity among young people. Letting them off the hook may worsen, not ease, the Neets crisis.
Amazon and the Erosion of Work
A 2020 TUC report on Amazon workers found a business model built on reducing workers’ rights. In the UK, pickers are expected to pack 300 items per hour. Employees work day or night shifts, with average weeks of 55 hours—especially during Christmas. In 2022, US Amazon turnover reached 150%.
Milburn acknowledges that work quality for young people has worsened. He notes warehouse jobs require speed, precision, and compliance with strict performance systems. Yet he calls this ‘industrial restructuring’—a phrase that implies order and purpose. The reality is anarcho-capitalism: a system where workers are treated as disposable, and lives are made nearly impossible.
The rational response to such cultures is at the heart of the Neets story: people recoil and retreat. When work feels dehumanising, young people withdraw from the labour market.
What the Solution Requires
Milburn’s short-term plans—like a youth opportunities service and spending on work entry—may ease the crisis. But they ignore deep problems. Work must be reinjected with respect, humanity, and decent pay. Without this, the Neets crisis—and the nation’s broader malaise—will persist.
As Wes Streeting once said, false hope is worse than no hope. The prime minister has suggested reindustrialisation and a rollback of 40 years of neoliberalism. A 10-year plan is due by year’s end. For now, we wait for a great leap forward—while the crisis continues.
Sources & further reading
Featured image: original publisher image. Via original publisher. Image source
