Tech and AI Trends

Race Realism Is Not Science

At this year’s World Economic Forum in Davos, US President Donald Trump stated that people from Somalia have low IQs. ‘I always say these are low-IQ people,’ he said. His son, Donald Trump Jr., made a similar claim about Haitian people in 2024. These statements contributed to the removal of protected status for both Somali and Haitian migrants in the US. Source: arstechnica.com.

What Is ‘Race Realism’?

These remarks reflect a broader trend in Western politics: the re-emergence of racial views about human nature that have been largely discredited for over 70 years. Such views are often called ‘race realism’ or ‘race science.’ They claim racial groups differ in innate intelligence, behavior, or social outcomes based on supposed biological or evolutionary differences.

These claims lack scientific support. They rely on oversimplified, outdated, and flawed data. They fail to meet modern standards of scientific rigor and reproducibility.

Genetic Evidence Against Racial Differences

In the 1970s, evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin showed that most human genetic variation exists within populations—not between them. This means socially defined racial groups are not genetically distinct.

For example, skin color is an adaptation to sunlight, not a marker of race. Populations in equatorial regions have more melanin to protect against UV radiation. Those in higher latitudes have lighter skin to absorb more sunlight for vitamin D. These traits are tied to geography, not race.

Similarly, the ability to digest milk has evolved independently in Africa, Europe, and Asia. Far-right claims that it is an ‘Aryan’ trait are scientifically false and culturally harmful.

Human History Shows No Genetic Purity

Recent ancient DNA studies reveal a long history of migration, intermarriage, and gene flow across continents. There is no evidence of genetically ‘pure’ populations.

Human evolution has involved continuous mixing. This means no racial group is biologically distinct or superior. The idea of a biological hierarchy among races is both scientifically invalid and historically inaccurate.

The ‘Cold Winter Theory’ Is Flawed

One common argument is that harsher climates in Europe and East Asia led to greater intelligence. This theory assumes that early humans faced unique environmental pressures outside Africa.

But early human groups migrated across diverse African regions—like the Sahara and the Nile Valley—facing extreme heat, drought, and food scarcity. The same pressures applied to all human groups.

Moreover, this theory ignores decades of research showing that human intelligence evolved through social complexity—not climate. Humans developed advanced cognitive abilities to manage relationships, resolve conflicts, and cooperate.

Intelligence Is Not a Single Trait

IQ tests only measure specific abilities—like logic and memory. They ignore social intelligence, creativity, emotional reasoning, and practical problem-solving.

Computer generated image evoking the double helix of DNA, composed of bright colored features on a black background.
Computer generated image evoking the double helix of DNA, composed of bright colored features on a black background.. Via original publisher. · Source

Research in evolutionary psychology shows the human brain evolved to navigate complex social environments. From early hunter-gatherers to modern societies, humans have spent most of their time managing relationships, competing for mates, and coordinating groups.

Science Does Not Support Racial Differences

There is no consensus in mainstream science that racial groups differ in innate cognitive ability. Differences in outcomes—like education or income—are rooted in social, economic, and historical factors.

For example, Africa’s development challenges stem from colonialism, unequal trade, and systemic inequality—not from supposed ‘innate intellectual deficiency’ of its populations.

A History of Harmful Science

Early 20th-century ‘race science’ justified eugenics—policies that led to the sterilization of thousands of people in the US, Canada, and beyond. These policies targeted marginalized groups and were directly linked to the Nazi regime’s ‘final solution’ to eliminate ‘undesirable’ populations.

After WWII, the scientific community largely rejected race science due to its role in human rights violations and its failure to meet scientific standards.

How Race Science Persists Today

Despite this, a small network continues to promote race science. In the 1960s, the journal Mankind Quarterly became a key platform. It was funded by the Pioneer Fund, established in the 1930s by a US textile magnate to support anti-desegregation research.

The Pioneer Fund continues to fund race science. It supports organizations like the Human Diversity Foundation, now rebranded as Polygenic Scores LLC—a central hub for promoting and spreading these views.

Academic Publishing and Gatekeeping

While race science is absent from genetics or evolutionary biology journals, it appears in some mainstream psychology journals—especially those focused on intelligence and evolutionary psychology.

The journal Intelligence has published many such articles. Its editors have defended these publications as part of academic freedom and robust debate.

However, academic debate should not legitimize pseudoscientific claims. Science advances through rigorous, transparent, and reproducible research—not through untested or unverified hypotheses.

Professional Consequences and Institutional Responses

Several figures have faced consequences. Philippe Rushton was sanctioned by his Canadian university in the 1990s. His position was preserved due to Edward O. Wilson’s intervention.

Nathan Cofnas maintained his postdoctoral roles at Cambridge and Ghent, though his college affiliation was ended. Teaching restrictions were imposed. He claims he is entitled to free inquiry and has been misunderstood.

University College London discovered that the race science community held conferences—called the ‘London Conferences on Intelligence’—without university knowledge. UCL stopped future events. Elsevier, the publisher of Intelligence, appointed new editors committed to rigorous and socially responsible science.

Public Outreach and Social Media

The network operates Aporia magazine, which promotes race science with overt political messaging. One article argued that eugenics could solve Africa’s economic challenges, claiming artificial selection for higher intelligence is needed to improve populations deemed ‘innately unintelligent.’

Such claims are scientifically invalid and deeply harmful. They suggest state-led genetic interventions based on racial assumptions.

Financial and Political Backing

The movement receives significant private funding. Andrew Conru, a US businessman, withdrew support after a report exposed the network’s activities.

The US Ambassador to Belgium intervened when Ghent University launched an investigation into Cofnas’s hiring—showing political actors are actively involved.

Why This Matters

These ideas are not confined to academia. They spread widely on social media—especially on X (formerly Twitter), where figures like Elon Musk amplify them.

Such platforms allow rapid spread of misinformation, especially when combined with emotional appeals and national identity narratives. Far-right movements use these ideas to justify immigration policies and social divisions.

Academic freedom allows exploration of ideas—but not at the expense of scientific validity. True freedom requires evaluation through rigorous, peer-reviewed processes. When one side relies on flawed or unscientific arguments, science regresses.

Race science is fundamentally pseudoscientific. It misrepresents genetics, distorts intelligence research, and relies on outdated ideologies. The scientific consensus is clear: all human groups share the same cognitive potential.

Differences in outcomes stem from social, economic, and historical factors—not biology. The persistence of these views reflects deeper societal issues: racism, inequality, and the misuse of language to justify exclusion.

By exposing the flaws in race science, we protect public understanding and prevent the spread of harmful ideologies. This is not just academic—it is a moral imperative. Only when public discourse is grounded in evidence can we build a future where human diversity is celebrated, not feared.

Sources & further reading

Featured image: Computer generated image evoking the double helix of DNA, composed of bright colored features on a black background.. Via original publisher. Image source

Show More

Related Articles

Back to top button