Erin Murphy, best known for playing Tabitha Stephens on the classic 1960s sitcom Bewitched, has made a surprising admission decades after the show ended.
Erin Murphy on Never Watching Early Episodes
Murphy said she only began watching the show when it switched to color in season three.
She explained: 'I've never seen the black-and-white episodes. I still keep thinking, "Oh, I'll sit down and watch them. Maybe I'll do a Facebook live or something." I've just never seen them.'
While she has seen brief clips—perhaps from reruns or promotions—she has never watched a full episode from the first two seasons.
Why the Character Grew in Importance
For the show’s first two seasons, both Erin and her twin sister Diane Murphy shared the role of Tabitha Stephens.
The twins were used to show sibling rivalry and the contrast between witchcraft and everyday life.
By season three, Erin took on the role alone. The character grew in importance, leading to a spin-off titled Tabitha’s World.
As Murphy said: 'Right before the third season, they wanted to expand the role of Tabitha. So they had a couple different sets of twin babies for season 2, but for season 3 they were going to color, and they knew they wanted the character to have a bigger part.'
Revival Talks and Creative Ideas
For decades, there have been discussions about reviving Bewitched.
The original cast and creator Bill Asher have long wanted to bring the show back in some form.
Murphy recalled: 'We were meeting regularly. He had artists draw me because they were talking about doing a series that combined live action and animation.'

This concept aimed to modernize the show while keeping its whimsical tone.
Still, Murphy said some ideas didn’t work. 'There were talks about doing shows and the scripts were really awful,' she said. 'We never wanted to do a reunion like Bewitched 40 years later. Unless it’s equal to the original show, there’s no reason to do it.'
What This Means for Fans
No official revival has been launched yet.
But the fact that the original team has long explored new formats shows lasting interest in the show.
Murphy’s warning about script quality suggests any revival must match the original show’s tone and character depth.
Her own experience—never watching the early episodes—shows how even beloved characters can remain distant to their original performers.
That underscores the need to preserve the original show’s integrity in any new version.
Though no new series has been confirmed, the conversation around revival continues.
The original show remains a cultural touchstone, and its legacy lives on through fan engagement, nostalgia, and the enduring appeal of its characters and themes.
For more on classic TV and its impact, see the original article.
Sources & further reading
Featured image: BEWITCHED – Cast Gallery – July 19, 1971. ELIZABETH MONTGOMERY;ERIN MURPHY;DICK SARGENT;DAVID LAWRENCE. Via original publisher. Image source
